Buying a used car

Cheapest Cars to Insure: How to Shortlist Without a Ranking

The engine, price, parts and theft traits that make a car cheap to insure, and how to shortlist and quote real cars by reg.

The cheapest cars to insure share a profile rather than a badge: a modest engine, a sensible price when new, parts that are easy to get, repairs that don’t need a specialist, and a model thieves don’t go after. Those traits keep a car’s insurance group low. What you actually pay then depends on you, so the only reliable way to find the cheapest car to insure for you is to shortlist on those traits and quote each car by its reg before you buy.

We don’t publish a list of named models here, on purpose. Group ratings change, a list can’t know your age or postcode, and a “top 10” can push you towards a car that’s cheap to insure but wrong in other ways. Instead, this guide sets out what makes a car cheap to insure, how to shortlist, and the checks that stop a cheap quote turning into an expensive car. Our sources are government pages checked on 20 November 2026, the main one being the Motor Insurance Taskforce’s final report from December 2025.

What makes a car cheap to insure?

Insurers price from expected claims. In the taskforce’s words, the number and size of claims drive premiums, so a car is cheap to insure when claims on it are few and modest. Here’s how that breaks down on the car itself.

TraitWhy it lowers the costHow to judge it on a used car
Small, low-power engineLower speeds and lower repair bills on averageBHP check by reg and the engine size on the DVLA record
Low price when newCheaper to replace if it’s written offBase trims over top trims of the same model
Simple, common partsThe report names parts shortages and “more complex and expensive cars” as cost driversFewer sensors and camera units in bumpers and mirrors
Low theft appealThe report names “increasing numbers of car thefts” as a cost driverAsk insurers; check the car isn’t recorded stolen
Standard specModifications add risk and must be declaredCompare the car spec check with the car

There’s a number behind the repair point. Insurers paid out £3 billion on motor claims in the third quarter of 2025, the report says, citing the ABI, and almost two-thirds of it, £1.9 billion, was spent repairing vehicles. A car that’s quick and cheap to fix sits on the right side of that figure.

How to shortlist cheap cars to insure without a ranking

  1. Pick the class first. Decide the size and body you need. Insurance should narrow the choice within a class, not decide the class.
  2. Choose the lowest-power version you’d be happy with. Within a model, the smallest engine and base trim usually sit lowest; confirm with a group checker.
  3. Look up each version’s group. Our car insurance groups guide explains how to read a group and where to find it.
  4. Quote real cars, by reg. When you find adverts, run quotes with the actual registration. That catches differences between versions you might not spot.
  5. Check each car’s records. The cheapest quote is only useful on a car that’s what it claims to be. See the checks below.

Cheapest cars to insure for new and young drivers

The car matters less for a new driver than the driver does, which is frustrating but true. The taskforce report says “there is evidence to suggest that younger drivers and those with less experience carry a higher risk”, and that criteria such as “a driver’s age and where they live” still count in standard policies. A low-group car helps; it won’t make a 17-year-old’s premium look like a 45-year-old’s.

Two things the report mentions can help. Telematics, or a black box, prices from how the car is driven, including “miles driven, roads used, speed, time of day and braking patterns”, and the report says lower-risk drivers in high-risk groups who take one “may be offered a lower premium”. And the report says uptake remains low, so it’s worth asking about.

When a quote is too cheap: ghost broking

New drivers chasing a low price are the main target of fake cover. The taskforce report describes “fake insurance offers sold online by illegal intermediaries (commonly known as ‘ghost broking’)”, sold to “motorists who unknowingly purchase invalid cover”, and notes a campaign aimed at young drivers about fake deals sold online. The warning signs are a price far below every other quote, a seller on social media or a messaging app, payment by bank transfer to a person, and documents sent as a screenshot. Check any policy appears on askMID, the database GOV.UK points to for checking whether a vehicle is insured, before you drive.

Fake cover counts as no cover. The penalty for driving uninsured, per GOV.UK on 20 November 2026, starts at 6 points and £300 on the spot, and a court can go further with an unlimited fine and a driving ban.

A cheap-to-insure car still has running costs

Insurance is one line in the budget. These are the other fixed costs you can read from GOV.UK before you buy, so you can compare cars on more than one number.

CostWhat decides itFigure from GOV.UK
Road tax, cars registered from 1 April 2017One flat yearly rate from the second payment; dearer cars (over £40,000 list price, or £50,000 if electric) add a supplement for five years£200, or £640 with the supplement (GOV.UK rate tables, 20 Nov 2026)
Road tax, cars first registered 2001-2017Thirteen CO2 bands, lettered A-MYearly payment runs from £20 at the bottom band to £790 at the top
Road tax, older cars (pre-March 2001)Whether the engine is above or below 1,549cc£230 a year for the smaller engines, £375 for the larger
MOTMaximum fee set by DVSA£54.85 for a car (read 14 Nov 2026)
London ULEZ, if the car doesn’t meet the standardEuro 4 petrol, Euro 6 diesel (TfL)£12.50 a day

Among cars from the 2001-2017 tax system, a small low-emission model can land in a cheap tax band and a low insurance group together. Look at both: a car tax check shows the rate the DVLA holds, and a ULEZ check shows whether the zone charge applies.

Checks that keep a cheap car cheap

A low quote on a car with a hidden past isn’t a bargain. These records change what you’d pay, what you’d have to declare, or whether you keep the car at all.

  • Write-off category. A low asking price is often the first sign of one, and GOV.UK notes that a retained Cat S car has its category added to the DVLA record. Tell the insurer when you quote; a car write-off check shows it.
  • Outstanding finance. If money is owed on the car, the finance company may have a claim on it. A car finance check reads the agreements registered against it.
  • Stolen marker. A stolen car check reads the police record.
  • Mileage. Quotes ask for your expected miles; the car’s own mileage history at each MOT is in the free MOT check, and the full report flags readings that don’t add up.
  • Identity. The VIN on the car should match the record. Our VIN decoder guide shows how to read one.

Run the checks on the car you’ve chosen

A free reg check gives you the engine size, fuel, first registration, tax and MOT history: everything you need to choose the right version on a quote form. When the quote is in and you’re ready to pay, the full HPI check covers finance, write-offs and theft; the sample report shows the layout.

Questions about cheap cars to insure

What are the cheapest cars to insure?

Cars with small engines, low prices when new, common parts and low theft appeal, which keeps their insurance group low. Shortlist on those traits, then quote each car by its reg, because your own details decide the final price.

Why don’t you list the cheapest models?

Groups change, a list can’t account for you, and our sources for this guide are government pages, which don’t rank models. A quote on the actual car is the only figure that counts.

Is a low insurance group enough for a new driver?

It helps, but the government’s taskforce report notes that younger and less experienced drivers carry a higher risk, and age and postcode still count. A black box policy may help; ask insurers.

Do cheaper cars always cost less to insure?

Not always. A cheap car with costly or scarce parts, high theft appeal or a modified spec can cost more to insure than a dearer, simpler one.

Is a Cat N car cheaper to insure?

Not necessarily. Each insurer sets its own approach to a recorded write-off. Declare the category and compare quotes before you buy.

How can I tell if cheap car insurance is genuine?

Be wary of a price far below other quotes, a seller on social media and payment to a person. The government’s taskforce describes this as ghost broking. Check the policy shows on askMID before you drive.

Does a reg check show insurance costs?

No. What it gives you is the engine, fuel, registration date, tax and MOT record, which is what an insurer’s form asks for. The paid report is where loans, write-offs and thefts show up.

Free vehicle checkMOT history, mileage, tax and MOT

Free car check